Fanelli, Evans & Patel, P.C.
Free Initial Consultation
Home & Hospital Visits Available

Local 570-221-6541
Toll free 800-858-1532

Is a doctor's apology admissible in a malpractice case?

In the legal system, even the simplest of issues can become complicated in some cases. This is because a seemingly minor detail can have major legal significance, whether Pottsville residents realize it or not.

For instance, last week this blog discussed the frustration many patients have when their doctors refuse to apologize after a medical error occurs. Often times, doctors do not want to apologize because they may believe the apology can be used against them in a later medical malpractice case.

In order to address this situation, many states around the country have enacted laws encouraging physicians to apologize for medical errors. Pennsylvania is among these states, as it enacted a statute known as the Benevolent Gesture Medical Professional Liability Act.

The Act makes so-called benevolent gestures, such as apologies, inadmissible as evidence of liability in a medical malpractice action. In other words, if a doctor apologizes for causing a mistake, that apology typically cannot be used as evidence against the doctor in a later lawsuit.

However, there are limits to this rule. Under the statute, statements of negligence or fault relating to an accident are not covered by the statute. Accordingly, a doctor who admits to being negligent cannot prevent those statements from coming into evidence in the case under the statute. These distinctions are thus very important, as the difference between a basic apology and a statement regarding negligence can make all the difference in the case in terms of whether the statement is admissible as evidence. This, in turn, can make an impact on whether the judge or jury finds the doctor negligent for the medical error.

Source: Pennsylvania General Assembly, "Benevolent Gesture Medical Professional Liability Act," accessed on April 2, 2016

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

How Can We Help You Today?

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Recent Results

Contractor Subcontractor Cases

  • $1 million Board of Claims verdict for a New York pipeline contractor against the DEP for a mine reclamation project outside Tamaqua.
  • $1 million recovery for a local general contractor against Blue Mountain School District involving the construction of a new elementary school.
  • $185,000 American Arbitration Association verdict for a Hazleton sitework contractor against a Montgomery County real estate developer.
  • $65,000 Schuylkill County verdict for a Luzerne County contractor against a Schuylkill County businessman, which included interest, costs and attorney's fees under the Prompt Pay Act.
  • Millions of dollars in settlements of numerous other construction claims throughout eastern Pennsylvania against private owners, school districts, municipalities and other governmental bodies.

Read More >

Criminal Defense

  • Acquittal on all felony charges against the target defendant in the internationally covered Shenandoah Hate Crime case.
  • Acquittal of a local police officer charged with multiple felonies arising out of a traffic stop involving illegal ATV riders.
  • Acquittal of a local contractor charged with rape. This case was one of the first challenges to DNA evidence in Schuylkill County.
  • Acquittal of a man charged with DUI by a State Trooper who boasted the highest DUI arrest and conviction rate in Schuylkill County.
  • Acquittal of a prominent local businessman charged with duct taping his ex-girlfriend following a domestic dispute.
  • Acquittal of a local tax collector charged with embezzling thousands of dollars in tax revenues from a local municipality.
  • Successful plea bargain which involved dismissal of first degree murder charges for a Shenandoah woman charged with killing her husband with a knife during a domestic dispute.
  • Acquittal of a Schuylkill County woman charged with homicide by vehicle while DUI. The client was initially found guilty when represented by a prior lawyer. She then came to our Firm, and we proceeded to get her a new trial on appeal and successfully defend her in the second trial.
  • Not Guilty by reason of insanity verdict for a Schuylkill County man charged with multiple assault-related crimes after holding police at bay with a loaded shotgun. This case was the first successful Insanity Defense cases in Schuylkill County.

Read More >

Medical Malpractice

  • $2.8 million Schuylkill County jury verdict for a woman's whose breast cancer was misdiagnosed. This remains the largest jury verdict in a Schuylkill County malpractice case in recent history.
  • $1.3 million mid-trial settlement in a Schuylkill County malpractice case involving the death of a woman who developed an undiagnosed infection following a burn injury.
  • $1.2 million settlement in a malpractice case involving a young woman who received improper radiation treatment for cervical cancer.
  • $1 million mid-trial settlement for a Schuylkill County woman who received permanent eye damage following a botched endoscopic procedure.
  • $975,000 settlement for an 18 month old infant whose infection was misdiagnosed for chickenpox and went untreated.
  • $950,000 Lehigh County malpractice settlement for a Schuylkill County man permanently injured by a botched arterial embolism procedure.
  • $750,000 pre-trial settlement against a doctor and hospital involving the death of a husband and father caused by a misdiagnosed stroke.
  • $700,000 Dauphin County malpractice settlement for a woman whose RSD was misdiagnosed.
  • $450,000 settlement against an Obstetrician who caused permanent facial nerve damage to a baby boy while using forceps during delivery.

Read More >

Personal Injury

  • $2.5 million settlement for a woman killed in a Lebanon County car crash.
  • $1.6 million New Jersey settlement for a New Jersey woman permanently injured by a speeding tractor trailer.
  • $950,000 mid-trial settlement for a Schuylkill County man who suffered a severe leg fracture after a crash on Route 901.
  • $750,000 settlement for a Schuylkill County man injured in a motorcycle crash.
  • $690,000 Schuylkill County jury verdict for a motorcyclist who lost a leg after a driver ran a red light and pulled out in front of him.
  • $650,000 New Jersey state court settlement against national garment manufacturers and retailers after an infant suffered third degree burns over most of his body because his pajamas did not meet minimum federal requirements for flame resistance.
  • $500,000 verdict for a Schuylkill County pedestrian who suffered back injury in crash
  • $500,000 jury verdict in Schuylkill County for a man who suffered severe orthopedic injuries in a car crash on Route 895.
  • $375,000 jury verdict in Schuylkill County involving a man who suffered a shattered ankle when a truck pulled out in front of him.

Read More >

Workplace Incidents

  • $17 million mid-trial settlement in Philadelphia County for two workers killed in an industrial explosion.
  • $4.5 million Allegheny County settlement for a steelworker who lost his legs in an industrial accident caused by international manufacturers.
  • $3 million settlement for a Schuylkill County man who was permanently injured by a defective piece of heavy construction equipment.
  • $3 million Philadelphia County settlement for a father and son killed in a construction site trench collapse.
  • $550,000.00 settlement for an Allegheny County man who fell through a hatch on a roof.
  • $550,000.00 settlement for a Berks County man who was burned when a cap blew off a pipe.

Read More >

Wrongful Death

  • $2.3 million Philadelphia County verdict for the parents of a son who was fatally assaulted leaving a bar by patrons who continued to be served alcohol after they were visibly intoxicated.
  • $1.75 million settlement for a father who died in a carbon monoxide poisoning incident caused by a defective furnace in a rental property.
  • $500,000 settlement for a Schuylkill County man who died of mesothelioma.

Read More >

Articles

Location

Fanelli, Evans & Patel, P.C.
1 Mahantongo Street
Pottsville, PA 17901


Phone: 570-221-6541
Toll Free: 800-858-1532
Fax: 570-622-5336
Pottsville Law Office Map

FindLaw Network
Super Lawyers Million Dollar Advocates Forum Pennsylvania Association For Justice Schuylkill County Bar Association American Association For Justice
We Accept Visa We Accept Mastercard We Accept American Express